When the Loan Costs More Than the Rental Earns
Plenty of rentals being financed right now lose money on the borrowed part of the deal. They still qualify.
Two numbers decide it, and you can run both on a napkin.
The first is what the building earns. Take the rent after vacancy, taxes, insurance, repairs, and management, before any loan payment. Divide by the price. Call it the yield. A $500,000 property netting $25,000 a year earns $5 for every $100 of price.
The second is what the money costs. Take the full annual loan payment, principal and interest, and divide by the loan amount. Lenders call it the loan constant. On a lot of rentals today, that number lands well above the yield.
When the second number is bigger than the first, every dollar you borrow pulls your return down instead of pushing it up. That's negative leverage. Picture a building earning $5 per $100 of price, financed with money that costs $8 per $100 borrowed. The more you borrow, the worse your cash on cash looks.
Here's why it still gets approved. A DSCR loan asks one question: does the rent cover the payment? With a big enough down payment, the answer is yes, even when the leverage works against you. The ratio passing tells you the loan is safe for the lender. It doesn't tell you the loan is good for you.
None of this means don't buy. It means know which bet you're making. In a negative leverage deal, the return comes from rent growth, appreciation, or a future refinance, not from the spread between yield and debt. That's a legitimate bet. It's just a different one from the deal most people think they're buying.
Three ways investors handle it:
- Put more down and accept a smaller but positive spread. - Buy where the yield clears the cost of debt, which is usually not the prettiest zip code. - Go in knowingly, with reserves sized for a few years of thin cash flow.
If you have a rental under contract or in your sights and want the two numbers run on it, send it here.
Chad
Chad Villacorta | NMLS #2636410 West Capital Lending | Equal Housing Opportunity Educational content, not a rate quote or commitment to lend. Subject to credit approval and property qualification.
--- *Author: Chad Villacorta, mortgage broker at West Capital Lending (NMLS #2636410). Licensed in 34 states. Estimate only, not a loan commitment. Subject to credit approval and underwriting.*
Subject to credit approval and property qualification.
West Capital Lending | NMLS #2636410 | Subject to credit approval and property qualification.


